By Aidan Joly
The reign of UConn being the best team in the Big East came to an end during the 2024-25 season, with another program stepping up.
That program was St. John’s, who won the league for the first time in more than two decades to cap off what was a dominant season in the program’s second season under Hall of Fame coach Rick Pitino.
Surely, the Johnnies will be back for 2025-26. Who are the other top jobbers? Take a look at each of the 11 teams.
St. John’s Red Storm
2024-25: 31-5 (18-2 Big East), lost in NCAA second round
St. John’s best season in more than two decades came to a close in the second round of the tournament, much earlier than many anticipated. Still, it came with a Big East title and a No. 2 seed in the tournament.
This year, it will be one key returner along with several transfer portal adds trying to bring Rick Pitino’s squad to the second weekend.
Zuby Ejiofor is the guy who is back for St. John’s after he averaged 14.7 PPG last season, good for second on the team. He is joined by six players who averaged in double figures at their last stops. That group is headlined by Bryce Hopkins, who has had injury issues over the past two seasons and has played just 17 games over two seasons, but he has been brilliant when healthy.
He is joined by Oziyah Sellers, who had 13.7 PPG at Stanford, Joson Sanon, who had 11.9 PPG at Arizona State, Ian Jackson who had 11.9 PPG at North Carolina and Dylan Darling, who had 19.9 PPG at Idaho State. Dillon Mitchell had 9.9 PPG at Cincinnati.
In addition, Handje Tamba had 10.5 PPG at Milligan University, a NAIA school in Tennessee.
This is a star-studded group with the arguably the best coach in the game. They can go deep.
Creighton Bluejays
2024-25: 25-11 (15-5 Big East), lost in NCAA second round
The Bluejays only return one key player in Jackson McAndrew along with two role guys in Jasen Green and Isaac Traudt, but both of the latter guys are candidates to take a step up in 2025-26.
Coach Greg McDermott brought in two of Iowa’s three leading scorers from last season in Owen Freeman and Josh Dix, who should both have very important roles on this team. He also brings in Blake Harper, who had 19.5 PPG at Howard and was named the MEAC player of the year as a freshman. Nik Graves had 17.5 PPG at Charlotte as well.
As for freshman, the Bluejays bring in Hudson Greer, a top-50 type prospect.
Overall, the Bluejays once again look like a team that will be playing in March. McDermott always seems to have his teams humming all year and this will be no different.
UConn Huskies
2024-25: 24-11 (14-6 Big East), lost in NCAA second round
After back-to-back national titles in 2023 and 2024, the Huskies looked like mere mortals in 2024-25, but they still went to the second round of the tournament and won 24 games.
For 2025-26, coach Dan Hurley has done a nice job at re-tooling his group. He does return Solo Ball and Alex Karaban, who both had 14+ points per game for last year’s squad and will be relied on again for on offense. Tarris Reed (9.6 PPG) is also back, as is role player Jaylin Stewart (5.4 PPG).
The biggest portal get for the Huskies is Silas Demary Jr., who had 13.5 PPG on a Georgia team that played in the NCAA tournament. Malachi Smith, who had 10.4 PPG for a solid Dayton team, joins him. Dwayne Koroma had 11.4 PPG for Le Moyne and Alec Millender had 8.2 PPG at IU Indy.
As for freshmen Braylon Mullins and Eric Reibe lead the charge as top-25 ESPN prospects, and they are joined by a pair of four-stars in Jacob Furphy and Jacob Ross.
This is a team that will be back towards the top of the Big East. As long as they have the Hurley sauce, they will be.
Xavier Musketeers
2024-25: 22-12 (13-7 Big East), lost in NCAA first round
It will more or less be an entirely new team for first year coach Richard Pitino, who takes over for Sean Miller after Miller left to take the job at Texas.
It will be a big flux of mid-major talent coming to Xavier, but six of them scored in the double figures. Those include All Wright (15.5 PPG at Valparaiso), Gabriel Pozzato (14.9 PPG at Evansville), Mier Panoam (13 PPG at North Dakota), Malik Moore (12.6 PPG at Montana), Tre Carroll (12.2 PPG at Florida Atlantic) and Isaiah Walker (10.8 PPG at Belmont).
Pitino also brings in a pair of role guys from his last job at New Mexico, Filip Borovicanin and Jovan Milicevic.
It will be interesting to see how all of these guys come together for a first year coach. Pitino won big at New Mexico, can he replicate it at Xavier?
Marquette Golden Eagles
2024-25: 23-11 (13-7 Big East), lost in NCAA first round
Coach Shaka Smart has become one of the best coaches in the country when it comes to player retention and this year is no different.
Marquette will return nine players for its 2025-26 roster. It does lose its top three scorers from last year due to eligibility, but does return multiple important players in Chase Ross and Ben Gold, along with role guys in Sean Jones, Royce Parham and Zaide Lowery.
Sheek Pearson is the top recruit coming to Milwaukee, and he is joined by fellow top-100 guys in Nigel James, Michael Phillips II and Adrien Stevens.
Overall, this is a team that has some replacing talent to do, but Marquette tends to find a way with plenty of returning talent.
Villanova Wildcats
2024-25: 21-15 (11-9 Big East), lost in Crown semifinals
It will be almost an entirely new roster for new coach Kevin Willard, who returns to the Big East following a stint at Maryland. He replaces Kyle Neptune, who was fired after three underwhelming seasons.
The main addition here is Devin Askew, who started his career at Kentucky before stops at Texas and Cal, before he finally found his footing at Long Beach State, averaging 18.9 PPG. Zion Stanford comes over from city rival Temple after averaging 13.1 PPG last season, and Bryce Lindsay (James Madison) and Duke Brennan (Grand Canyon) each averaged in double figures last season.
One carry over was a role guy in Tyler Perkins, who had 6.3 PPG last season. Willard also has three role guys following him from Maryland in Tafara Gapare, Malachi Palmer and Braden Pierce. Acaden Lewis, a top-40 prospect, is the lead freshman here.
Villanova has fallen on hard times since Jay Wright retired in 2022. Willard, a proven winner, will try to being the Wildcats back to the top of the league.
Georgetown Hoyas
2024-25: 18-16 (8-12 Big East), lost in Crown quarterfinals
Year two in Ed Cooley’s rebuild of the program showed tangible progress, winning six more conference games and nine more games overall.
He will try to make the next step in 2025-26. The team’s second leading scorer in Malik Mack returns for this season after averaging 12.9 PPG last season. He will be expected to take on the brunt of the scoring. Caleb Williams and Julius Halaifonua both had some minutes last year and are back.
From the portal, the key add here is KJ Lewis, who had 10.8 PPG on a team that went to the Sweet 16. Langston Love had 8.9 PPG at Baylor and Jeremiah Williams, who had 7.0 PPG at Rutgers, both join the fold too.
The Hoyas have talent on paper. Now, Cooley will try to get a program that hasn’t played in the tournament since 2021, and only once since 2015, back in the bracket.
Providence Friars
2024-25: 12-20 (6-14 Big East), no postseason
It was a disappointing season in year two of the Kim English era for the Friars, the program’s worst season in more than a decade.
Something had to give here. English brought in a key contributor to a NCAA tournament teams in Jason Edwards, who was Vanderbilt’s leading scorer as the Commodores reached the tournament for the first time since 2017, as well as Duncan Powell, who had 12.2 PPG at Georgia Tech. Other additions include Cole Hargrove who had 9.9 PPG at Drexel, Daquan Davis who had 8.8 PPG at Florida State and Jaylin Sellers, who had 6.0 PPG at UCF.
The Friars do return four rotation pieces in Corey Floyd Jr., Oswin Erhunmwunse, Ryan Mela and Rich Barron.
As for freshmen Jamier Jones is a top-50 prospect, while Jaylen Harrell is a solid four-star.
The key here for Providence is bouncing back. Do they have the pieces to do it?
Butler Bulldogs
2024-25: 15-20 (6-14 Big East), lost in Crown quarterfinals
Butler has continually struggled to compete as Thad Matta enters the fourth season of his second stint at Butler, and the Bulldogs took a step back in year three.
The Bulldogs had to do a ton of re-tooling. They do return Finley Bizjack, who had 10.3 PPG as a sophomore. Jamie Kaiser did not play last season but had 4.4 PPG at Maryland in 2023-24.
As for new guys, Jalen Jackson leads the way after he had 19.2 PPG at Fort Wayne last season. Yame Butler had 13.6 PPG at Drexel, Dayton Jones had 13.0 PPG at South Carolina State and Yohan Traore was a role guy at SMU.
One guy to be interested in is Michael Ajayi, who was once a star at Pepperdine and then averaged 6.5 PPG at Gonzaga last season. He could be heavily relied on.
Jack McCaffery and Azavier Robinson are both top-100 freshmen coming to Indianapolis.
It feels like Matta is entering the year on the hot seat. If Butler doesn’t show tangible improvement, it might be a new coach this time next year. We will see.
DePaul Blue Demons
2024-25: 14-20 (4-16 Big East), lost in Crown first round
The hiring of Chris Holtmann gave DePaul some credibility on the sidelines, but the first year of the Holtmann era in Chicago did not go overly well. However, it was still an improvement from 0-20 in the league, 3-29 overall mark two seasons ago.
The Blue Demons do bring back three decent pieces from last year’s team in CJ Gunn, Layden Blocker and NJ Benson, all of whom averaged over 9.0 PPG last season. Those three will likely carry the load this year.
Another guy who can carry the load is Kaleb Banks, who had 14.7 PPG at Tulane last season. Another guy, Brandon Maclin, scored in double figures at Radford. Jeremy Lorenz (Wofford), RJ Smith (Colorado) and Amsal Delalic (Pitt) all had varying roles at their last stops.
DePaul is easily the toughest job in power conference college basketball. It has not been to the tournament since 2004. Holtmann will be given a long leash to get this right. Even six or seven league wins would be seen as a big accomplishment.
Seton Hall Pirates
2024-25: 7-25 (2-18 Big East), no postseason
Seton Hall had a disaster of a 2024-25 season and is a prime example of having little NIL dollars as a power conference team can do to you.
It forced coach Shaheen Holloway to go deep into his bag to get players. Thankfully, he did get some.
Adam Clark (Merrimack) is the most productive of the bunch after he averaged 19.5 PPG at Merrimack last season. Elijah Fisher had 15.7 PPG at Pacific. TJ Simpkins (Elon) and Josh Rivera (Fordham) each scored in double figures last season too.
High major talent coming in includes AJ Staton-McCray (Miami), Trey Parker (NC State), Mike Williams III (LSU) and Patrick Suemnick (Oklahoma State), all of whom had varying levels of success.
The only freshman on the roster will be Najai Hines, who is a top-100 guy.
It’s an interesting collection of talent at Seton Hall for this season. It remains to be seen how it will all come together. It would be hard to be worse than last season.