By Aidan Joly
The Big 12 was the best league in college basketball in the 2022-23 season and it wasn’t close.
Now, for the 2023-24 season, it will be a season of transition. It is the first season of new additions Cincinnati, BYU, Houston and UCF and the final season of Oklahoma and Texas being in the league before those two leave for the SEC in 2024. Colorado, Arizona, Arizona State and Utah will join in the summer of 2024.
That being said, the league projects to be strong once again in 2023-24. Let’s get into breaking down each of the league’s 14 teams for this season.
Kansas Jayhawks
2022-23: 28-8 (13-5 Big 12), lost in Round of 32
The Jayhawks lost both of their top two scorers to the NBA in Jalen Wilson and Gradey Dick, but claimed the top prize in the transfer portal in Michigan’s Hunter Dickinson, who projects as the team’s best player right out of the gate.
Dickinson seems like a perfect fit for this group, which was one of the most talented rosters in the country even without him. The Jayhawks return Kevin McCullar, KJ Adams and DaJuan Harris, all of whom will have larger roles this season. Freshmen Elmarko Johnson and Chris Johnson are both very good recruits as well.
The talent here is overwhelming. Two question marks are the health of head coach Bill Self, who missed the team’s round of 32 loss to Arkansas as well as Texas transfer Arterio Morris, who is suspended from the program following a rape accusation. The Jayhawks project on paper as a top-2 team in the country on talent alone.
Houston Cougars
2022-23 in American Athletic: 33-3 (17-1 AAC), lost in Sweet 16
The system that coach Kelvin Sampson has in place is more of a plug-and-play one that anyone can really play in. That’s why losing Marcus Sasser and Jerace Walker to the NBA isn’t a huge loss. Case and point, when the Cougars made a run to the Elite Eight in 2022 without Sasser, the team’s best player at the time.
The Cougars return two solid core pieces in Jamal Shead and J’Wan Roberts after they played key roles in what was a top-5 team in the nation for most of 2022-23. Baylor transfer LJ Cryer was one of the better players in the portal and Houston landed him, as well as Temple transfer Damian Dunn. Emanuel Sharp should also have an increased role this season after averaging 5.9 points per game last year.
It will be interesting to see how the Cougars do in a league with much stiffer competition that in the American, but all signs point to a great season with a deep postseason run.
Texas Longhorns
2022-23: 28-8 (12-6 Big 12), lost in Elite Eight
The Longhorns had one of the better stories for the entire season in 2022-23, enduring a midseason coaching change and not missing a beat, ending up one game away from the Final Four.
That was enough for Rodney Terry to get the permanent head coaching gig.
The Longhorns lost just about everyone, but do return Tyrese Hunter, who averaged 10.1 points per game, and Dylan Disu, who averaged 9.1 per game. Texas does bring in two top transfers in Kadin Shedrick (Virginia) and Max Abmas (Oral Roberts), who project to be two of the team’s top three players. Freshman AJ Johnson will have a role, but will have to be developed over time.
The biggest question here remains Terry. In two previous head coaching gigs, he went 163-158 in 10 seasons in the Mountain West (Fresno State) – his first season there was in the WAC – and Conference USA (UTEP). How will be do here in a permanent job?
Kansas State Wildcats
2022-23: 25-9 (11-7 Big 12), lost in Elite Eight
Another one of the best stories in 2022-23, the Wildcats exceeded all expectations in 2022-23, winning 25 games and making the Elite Eight for just the third since since 1988 in Jerome Tang’s first season at the helm, including a signature win over Kansas in January.
The Wildcats lost both of their stars in Markquis Nowell and Keyontae Johnson. However, they re-tooled in the portal, picking up Tylor Perry (North Texas), Arthur Kaluma (Creighton) and Ques Glover (Samford), three unsung guys who are likely to make an impact.
They also return Nae’Qwan Tomlin and David N’Guessan. Overall, this Wildcats team is likely to take a step back, but still be a threat overall in the Big 12.
Baylor Bears
2022-23: 23-11 (11-7 Big 12), lost in Round of 32
The Bears averaged 13th in the NET rankings in the past five years, with usually one of the top rosters in the country. This might be a lower number this year.
The aforementioned LJ Cryer is gone, as is Adam Flagler, who elected to stay in the NBA Draft. In response coach Scott Drew hit the portal, adding RayJ Dennis (Toledo) and Jayden Nunn (VCU) as transfers. They project to be solid replacements for the two departures.
Jalen Bridges does return after averaging 10.3 points per game this past season. A pair of freshmen in JaKobe Walker and Miro Little should help right out of the gate as well.
Scott Drew is one of the best coaches in the country. Dennis and Nunn come from mid-majors, but Drew has proven he can get a lot out of that type of player, looking at what he did with Flagler and MaCio Teague. We will see.
Cincinnati Bearcats
2022-23 in American Athletic: 23-12 (11-7 American), lost in NIT quarterfinals
This will be the first season in the Big 12 for the Bearcats and coach Wes Miller after deep NIT run last March.
Viktor Lahkin and Aziz Bandoago are two of the most underrated centers in the country on a national level, and both of them return in 2023-24. However, there is not much to be said for the other positions. There is Georgetown transfer Primo Spears, who should be solid at the guard position. They bring in Butler transfer Simas Lukosius, who will provide another option in the frontcount.
Cincinnati will be a decent team in 2023-24, but there will surely be some growing pains as they adjust to a new, highly competitive league.
TCU Horned Frogs
2022-23: 22-13 (9-9 Big 12), lost in Round of 32
The Horned Frogs are coming off their second straight NCAA tournament appearance, something the program had not accomplished since 1952 and 1953.
Mike Miles is gone, but returner JaKobe Coles easily slides into having a larger role in his absence. Damion Baugh and Emanuel Miller return for the Horned Frogs as well. Coach Jamie Dixon did a solid job in the portal, picking up Oklahoma State transfer Avery Anderson III and Delaware’s Jameer Nelson Jr. Anderson will see the bigger role, but Nelson projects as about the fourth-best player in the roster.
It remains to be seen how large of a role freshman Jace Posey will have and that is something to monitor.
All in all, TCU should be in solid shape and will compete towards the middle of the league.
Iowa State Cyclones
2022-23: 19-14 (9-9 Big 12), lost in Round of 64
The Cyclones are positioned to be one of the youngest teams in the league following the losses of each of their top four scorers – Jared Holmes, Gabe Kalscheur, Caleb Grill and Osun Osunniyi – all to graduation.
Sophomore Tamin Lipsey will be thrust into a large role after showing some flashed as a freshman, a season where he averaged 7.2 points a game. UNLV transfer Keshon Gilbert will probably be the second-leading scorer, and Buffalo transfer Curtis Jones is likely to start.
A crop of freshman, Omaha Biliew, Milan Momcilovic and JT Rock, will need to develop quickly.
There will surely be some growing pains for the Cyclones at the start of the season, but it will be interesting to see how they progress as the season goes on.
BYU Cougars
2022-23 in WCC: 19-15 (7-9 WCC), no postseason
BYU had Ques Glover for a time this off-season before he re-opened his recruitments and landed with Kansas State, as mentioned before. That was a huge blow for the program as it tried to pick up a second star player.
That being said, Fousseyni Traore is a top-30 player in the country and will have a huge role. However, he will have to play in the post standing at 6-6, in a league where every team has a good center. They do have 6-11 Aly Khalifa, but Traore is much more talented. Spencer Johnson returns for the Cougars as well.
It will be fascinating to see how this team adjusts to the Big 12 buzzsaw, especially coming off a season in the WCC where it struggled to a degree.
UCF Knights
2022-23 in American Athletic: 19-15 (8-10 AAC), lost in NIT second round
UCF is another school joining the Big 12 this season. It has been a solid program for a while now under Johnny Dawkins. A lot of people seem to think that UCF will be something of a whipping boy for a bit, which could happen, but there is also a good shot the Knights can hold their own, even if the season ends towards the bottom of the league.
Darius Johnson is the guy to watch here. Most of the rest of the roster is not much to write home about. Sam Jose State transfer Ibrahima Diallo is a seven-footer who might be a defensive menace in the middle.
Defense has always been the key for Dawkins teams at UCF, and will have to hang its hat on that again this season.
Oklahoma State Cowboys
2022-23: 20-16 (8-10 Big 12), lost in NIT quarterfinals
Losing Kalib Boone and Moussa Cisse to the transfer portal is a huge blow to a team that missed the NCAA tournament last season. Two of the best big men in the nation, but barely playing over 20 minutes a game in coach Mike Boynton’s rotation. Who can blame them? That’s on Boynton and coaching. Avery Anderson III is gone to TCU, as well.
So, the Cowboys will have to lean on mid-major guards to lead the team. On paper, adding Javon Small (East Carolina) is a solid move. He had good stats with 15.8 points, 4.8 rebounds and 5.6 assists, but a lot of that came against much inferior competition. Louisiana-Monroe transfer Russell Harrison missed all of 2022-23, but is now eligible.
Bryce Thompson is back, but he was wildly inconsistent in 2022-23. John-Michael Wright will need to have a bigger role too.
All in all, things don’t look great. You might be looking at the worst team in the Big 12 here.
West Virginia Mountaineers
2022-23: 19-15 (7-11 Big 12), lost in Round of 64
One of the biggest storylines off the off-season came in Morgantown, after Bob Huggins was forced into retirement after using an anti-gay slur on a radio station and then getting a DUI.
Interim coach Josh Eilert, less than two seasons removed from being a DOBO, will lead the team this season.
The team’s biggest get in the portal was Syracuse transfer Jesse Edwards, who will likely be the team’s best player. Montana State transfer RaeQuan Battle and Arizona transfer Kerr Kriisa are both solid gets, but neither dramatically move the needle.
Tre Mitchell is the best returner here. Overall, it’s tough to get too excited about this tea, but maybe they can prove doubters wrong.
Texas Tech Red Raiders
2022-23: 16-16 (5-13 Big 12), no postseason
New coach Grant McCasland is fresh off of a NIT championship with North Texas and will have a good shot at coaching in the NCAA tournament with these Red Raiders.
Arizona State transfer Warren Washington will be key in leading this group, which does not have a ton of returning players. However, Pop Isaacs is one of those returners, back after averaging 11.5 points per game as a freshman in 2022-23. Joining Washington will be Devan Cambridge, who also comes to the program from Arizona State.
The outlook here looks decent. Time will tell.
Oklahoma Sooners
2022-23: 15-17 (5-13 Big 12), no postseason
The 2022-23 season did not go well in Norman, and this year’s edition might take a further step back.
The team’s best player is probably John Hugley IV, who averaged 8.0 points and 3.6 rebounds a game for Pittsbrgh in 2022-23. As for guys coming back, Milos Uzan is probably the best of the group after he averaged 7.6 points per game last year.
Siena transfer Javian McCollum was a star in the MAAC, and he now gets a challenge and a role to put himself into for the Sooners.
It’s likely that this team takes a step back, which is a shame. Porter Moser is a solid coach, but this is just not a good fit for him geographically. A move somewhere else before Oklahoma makes a move could be the best option for him if the season goes even more south.